top of page
Logo_BC_Primary_FullColour.png
Wellington Chamber Logo NoTag.png

Submission on Rating Policies Review

2 hours ago
10 min read

About Business Central


Business Central and the Wellington Chamber of Commerce represent around 3,500 businesses across Wellington and Central New Zealand, including around 1,000 in Wellington. We exist to help businesses grow, adapt and connect in an ever-changing environment.

 

Our position


Business Central supports a clear, staged reduction in Wellington’s commercial rating differential. The pathway should be published, reviewed annually and supported by transparent evidence about who benefits from Council spending.


Businesses carry a disproportionate share of Wellington’s rates burden.


Combined with rising water charges, insurance and other costs, this adds to the pressure on businesses to invest, employ and grow. What we consistently hear is that they do not see a corresponding return in the services and value they receive for the extra cost.


Wellington has the talent, businesses and sector strengths to grow. Council policy should support investment and growth, not add unnecessarily to the cost of doing business in the city.


Our longstanding priority remains reducing the commercial rates differential and securing earlier relief for businesses. We also oppose any move to land-value rating and ask Council to take it off the table: differential relief means little if it is outweighed by a much larger increase from changing the valuation system, and Council has not shown that land-value rating would benefit businesses.

 

What we are asking Council to do


We recommend that Wellington City Council:

  1. Reduce the commercial rates differential from 3.7:1 to 3.0:1 over three years, rather than the six-year transition in Council’s consultation, to provide earlier relief from Wellington’s disproportionate commercial rates burden. The pathway should be published and reviewed annually, supported by transparent evidence about who benefits from Council spending.


  2. Do not proceed with any further consideration of land-value rating. We oppose any move from capital-value to land-value rating and ask Council to take it off the table, given the disproportionate impact on commercial ratepayers. Changing systems now may be premature, given the prospect of future council amalgamation in Wellington and because neighbouring councils continue to use capital-value rating. With businesses already under pressure, Council should prioritise earlier commercial rates relief and other measures that reduce the cost of doing business.


What the evidence says


The commercial differential


Wellington is a national outlier


Wellington’s current commercial differential of 3.7:1 is the highest of any council in New Zealand, ahead of Dunedin (2.5:1), Auckland (2.4:1), Hamilton (2.2:1) and Christchurch (2.0:1).


The actual rates burden is also high


Commercial ratepayers contribute 48% of Wellington’s rates burden, compared with 31% in Auckland.


Infometrics found Wellington has the least affordable commercial rates when measured as a proportion of capital value (2.4%). By contrast, Porirua sits at 1.8%, Dunedin and Lower Hutt at 1.4%, and Auckland and Christchurch are the most affordable at 0.9%.


Wellington also had the least affordable commercial rates for office, CBD retail and accommodation properties among the locations compared.


Source: WCC Rates Affordability Report (Infometrics, 2026)


Rates are part of a cumulative cost burden


The rating review consultation cannot be viewed in isolation. Since 1 July 2026, Wellington businesses have already been absorbing significant, compounding cost increases across multiple fronts:

  • An average 5.9% Wellington City Council rates increase (including the sludge levy) [Source: WCC]

  • An average 9.7% Greater Wellington rates increase [Source: GWRC]

  • Separately billed water charges.

  • Significant insurance and seismic-strengthening costs [Source: Property Council]


High costs are holding back growth


Sense Partners’ indicative modelling suggests high business differentials increase the cost of operating in Wellington, reduce incentives for firms to expand, and raise barriers for new businesses entering the city.


Source: Sense Partners, Tax and the city – a closer look at the business differential and land taxation.


Land-value rating


Councils are moving towards capital value, not away from it


All councils neighbouring Wellington use capital value for rates. Nationally, 65% of councils use capital value, compared with 50% 20 years ago, and no council in New Zealand has changed back to a land-value rating system.


This direction, together with the prospect of future council amalgamation, reinforces our opposition to land-value rating.


Sources: QV, Rating values and Rating (national trend); WCC, Rating Policy Review Workshop Three (switching history).


If Council moves to land-value rating, the commercial differential could be pushed to 5.8:1 [Source: WCC]. This would further increase the disparity between commercial and residential rates and reinforce Wellington’s position as a national outlier.


The Impact is Uneven


The impact of shifting to land-value rating is uneven, with retail, heritage-protected buildings, and large-footprint businesses carrying a disproportionate share of the burden. Low-rise buildings in Te Aro, which house many retail and hospitality businesses, face sharp increases even though heritage protections and consenting rules prevent many of them from developing. Similarly, space-intensive community and suburban businesses such as supermarkets, garden centres, independent cinemas, car yards, and surface car parks face steep hikes simply because they require large areas of land to operate.


As widely highlighted during this consultation using Wellington City Council’s own rates calculator, and documented through the Voice for Wellington campaign, these increases threaten well-loved local institutions across the city. In the central city, hospitality operator Trinity Group’s Courtenay Place venue (Lulu) faces a 150% jump from around $68,000 to $170,000 a year, while nearby retailers such as Moore Wilson's on Tory Street and Briscoes on Taranaki Street could see increases of $321,000 and $273,000 respectively. Beyond the CBD, beloved suburban businesses face the same penalty for their land footprint, including Brooklyn’s family-run Penthouse Cinema, which projects an increase of over $77,000 a year, and Palmers Garden Centre in Miramar facing a $130,000 a year increase.


A higher rate on these properties will not encourage development. It is simply an added cost - one that risks forcing long-standing community venues to close or passing higher prices directly on to Wellington residents, shoppers, and commuters at the checkout, the ticket box, and the parking meter. Meanwhile, major commercial high-rises are projected to receive substantial decreases, with the 29-storey Majestic Centre saving over $700,000 and the Deloitte building saving more than $1 million.


Source: Wellington City Council's online rates calculator.


Why this matters for Wellington’s growth


Wellington’s population is in decline


Wellington city’s population decreased 0.6% in the year ended June 2026. Over the same period, Lower Hutt’s population grew by 0.7%, Upper Hutt’s by 0.5% and Kāpiti Coast’s by 0.2%, according to provisional Stats NZ estimates.



Wellington’s wider economic performance


Wellington’s regional economy continues to lag national growth. Infometrics’ provisional estimates show annual-average GDP growth of 0.8% in Wellington Region in the year to June 2026, compared with 1.7% nationally.



Council decisions impact business confidence


Our Business Confidence Survey shows that business sentiment is linked to confidence in Wellington’s direction. In Q4 2025, only 6.1% of respondents were satisfied with Council’s support for the business community and local economy, while 45.1% believed Wellington was heading in the wrong direction.


Businesses identified revitalising the CBD, controlling Council spending and improving transparency as their top priorities for the new Mayor. These priorities reinforce the important role Council plays in creating the conditions for business confidence.


Fiscal discipline, sensible rates, good infrastructure and visible progress in the city all help give businesses the confidence to invest, employ and grow.


Source: Wellington Chamber of Commerce Wellington Business Confidence Survey Q4 2025.


Taken together, the evidence on the differential, land-value rating and growth supports earlier relief from Wellington’s high commercial rates burden and weighs against any move to land-value rating. Rates are one of several cost pressures that can constrain investment, employment and growth in the city.


What our members are saying


Feedback from Wellington businesses points to two linked conclusions: commercial rates relief needs to come sooner, and Council should not move to land-value rating or make changes to the rating system without robust modelling of the combined effects. Businesses warn that relief from a lower differential could be outweighed by a valuation change, while water, insurance and other costs, alongside city-centre conditions, continue to affect the viability of operating and investing in Wellington. These anonymised accounts illustrate individual experiences and concerns.


Businesses want affordable costs and visible value for the rates they pay. Their feedback falls into three areas that mirror the evidence above: the commercial differential, land-value rating, and the conditions for growth.


The commercial differential: earlier relief and visible value


Business owners welcomed the reduction in the commercial differential in Council’s consultation but considered a six-year transition too slow for businesses facing significant cost pressures now. This feedback reinforces our call for earlier relief, alongside careful sequencing and Council savings to ensure the burden is not simply shifted elsewhere.


The scale of rates paid by some businesses illustrates the issue. One major infrastructure business reported paying around $7 million a year in rates. Another business owner reported a $1.2 million annual rates bill for its central Wellington site alone, saying the combined cost of rates, water and insurance materially affects decisions about investment, hiring and continued operation. The prospect of further rates increases, without a clear corresponding benefit, could see that business reconsider its presence in Wellington City and focus investment on its other sites across the wider region.


Business owners also questioned whether the level of rates they pay is being matched by Council action that supports economic activity and growth. They want to see a clearer connection between the contribution businesses make through rates and the conditions Council creates for them to succeed.


A Wellington retailer highlighted the need to bring more workers and customers into the central city to support trade. They saw this as an area where Council has an important role to play. Parking availability and cost, changing working patterns and street disruption were also identified as pressures affecting customer access and business activity.


“Council needs to be more enabling and engage with businesses as valued partners. We’re all in this together.” Business owner


Land-value rating: uneven impacts and development constraints


Business owners raised three consistent concerns about land-value rating: the size and unevenness of the increases for individual properties; that a change in rating would not make redevelopment viable for buildings shaped by past planning decisions or weak tenant demand; and that owners and tenants who cannot change their buildings would carry the cost. Some preferred a targeted approach if the aim is to discourage land banking, and for clear modelling of the combined effect with a lower differential.


The Council’s rates calculator and business-supplied examples illustrate how uneven the effects of land-value rating could be. One owner supplied a comparison for a central-city building showing annual rates of $263,482.51 under capital-value rating and $480,070.56 under the land-value rating option in Council’s consultation. Another reported projected increases of around 100% for their Courtenay Place businesses and about a 75% increase for one hotel, but a slight reduction for another hotel. Owners feared that increases of this scale could push already fragile businesses beyond viability.


A business owner who had recently moved from the wider Wellington region into Wellington City and bought a new venue said he was disappointed to learn that, if a move to land-value rating proceeds, his rates bill could be $20,000 higher than he had anticipated.


Owners of low-rise properties, particularly in Te Aro, argued that past Council planning decisions had shaped what could be built on their sites. Some buildings were fully developed for their intended purpose, while large-format retail, entertainment, workshop and light-industrial uses cannot readily move into high-rise formats. Land-value rating could therefore penalise businesses for constraints and operating needs that are not a matter of owner choice. 


“Council decisions over recent decades have shaped what we can build. Land-value rating would penalise low-rise properties without recognising those constraints.” — Business owner


One property owner said some buildings could not currently be developed because the business case did not stack up. Participants argued that penalties on rates alone would not resolve the underlying economics of development.


Multiple local business owners questioned who would occupy new buildings even if they were developed, expressing concern that there is insufficient demand to fill new spaces. Some said that even where their own rates might fall, any saving could be dwarfed by weaker tenant demand and wider damage to the business ecosystem. Council should assess demand for additional space, rather than assume that a shift to land-value rating will result in new buildings being developed and occupied.


Owners also warned about effects on tenants. They feared that rates passed through as operating expenses could make premises unaffordable for small creative businesses in Te Aro, undermining occupancy and recovery. Some questioned whether larger corporate occupiers in the CBD would benefit while smaller businesses faced higher costs.


Other participants argued that, if Council’s aim is to discourage land banking, it should take a targeted approach rather than a broad-brush change that could leave small business owners facing significantly higher rates.


Although owners welcomed a lower commercial differential, they questioned whether changing the valuation basis could outweigh that relief for affected properties. They wanted urgent discussion of the combined effects on owners and tenants who could not realistically change their buildings.


“We need clear explanations of how the proposals work together for owners and tenants who cannot realistically change their buildings.” — Business owner


Conditions for growth: shared priorities for Council action


The feedback highlighted four connected priorities:

  • Affordable costs and disciplined spending:  Participants wanted Council to find savings and efficiencies, set clearer spending priorities and recognise the cumulative burden of rates, power, insurance and water charges. Some said their businesses were no longer growing and needed relief or a reset. Business owners argued that Council should face the same discipline they had faced over the past five years, with visible restraint and less waste.

  • Conditions that enable investment: Participants linked development decisions to unstable returns and the combined costs of construction, development contributions and utilities. They also sought clarity on any vacant land charge.

  • Amalgamation plans need to be clearer: Some favoured delaying any possible changes to the rating system until the implications of possible council amalgamation were clearer.

  • Core services, access and partnership:  Businesses wanted a safe, clean city with reliable customer access and parking. Participants also wanted Council to engage with businesses as valued partners, rather than simply as a source of revenue.


Many participants described recent years as the most challenging on record, pointing to tough trading conditions fuelled by public sector job cuts, COVID-19, remote work, safety concerns, and seismic issues. Still, they remain optimistic that upcoming developments and the completion of major city projects will boost morale and spur investment. While welcoming the new mayor and council’s encouraging rhetoric and early progress in getting Wellington back on track, participants urged leadership not to risk the city’s recovery by taking a step backwards on rating changes.


One business owner summed it up: “I’m happy to pay my share, but in return I want a safe, clean environment where customers and people can get in and out of the city, find a car park and do business.”


Closing


Wellington has the potential to grow. Council’s rating policies should support that potential, not add to the pressures facing businesses.


Our priority is to reduce the commercial rates differential sooner, providing earlier relief and helping create the conditions for businesses to invest, employ and grow. We oppose any move to land-value rating: large and uneven increases could overwhelm that relief, and the combined impact on businesses, including owners and tenants of properties that cannot readily be redeveloped, would be too great.


Businesses also want earlier relief paired with visible savings and efficiencies, and core services that deliver value. They want a safe, clean and accessible city, and to be valued partners in Wellington’s recovery.


We welcome the opportunity to speak to this submission and to work constructively with Council on delivering earlier rates relief and engaging with businesses on the impacts of any change to the rating system.


Hayley Horan

CEO of Business Central, home of the Wellington Chamber of Commerce 


Contact_P.png

Get in touch

Phone: 

AdviceLine: 

0800 778 776

0800 800 362

Our Partner Networks
ExportNZ Logo_no tagWhite.png
BusinessNZ Logo White.png
NZCCI Logo White_4x.png
EMA_White_noTagline.png
Business South Inc White.png
bottom of page